IMO, the starting outfield should be Curtis Granderson, Nick Swisher and Andruw Jones. Why? Although Brett Gardner has speed, he is at best a sub par hitter.

Recently Gardner has raised his average to a whopping .233, still low and has only 6 extra base hits in 90 at bats...  I think he should only be used as a backup and in case of injuries. Let him pinch run, then you utilize his speed and he does not have to swing the bat.